And from a writing standpoint, I agree. fanfic is its own form, and being a good writer in other areas doesn’t automatically translate into writing good slash. And, yes, there were a lot of not particularly interesting posts recycling the same Siken quotes over and over.
But, still, the post hit me really viscerally.
I found out about Crush through fandom, but what I love about it isn’t really related to fandom. I’ve been working on writing a memoir, and I’ve really been struggling to figure out how to write about all the stupid, out of control shit I did when I was a pup. But Siken does it masterfully, writing with compassion and vivid detail. My boyfriend also died in my early 20s, and my grieving was also full of ghosts. So I basically can’t pick up Crush without crying. And I’ve sent copies to all my friends and told them they have to read it.
And I read the post and the comment thread to be saying that I was wrong to love Crush. That I was wrong to think that a book written by a man could resonate with me. And that I needed to restrict myself to writing by women.
Any time people, especially women of the older generation (I’m 42, so this is now my generation) start policing what women are allowed to squee over, it gets my dander up. I was always the girl who liked the wrong stuff: Jane’s Addiction, Hole, William Burroughs, Velvet Underground and Nico, On the Road, Billie Holiday, Kate Moss, All the worst counterculture assholes and all the tragic junkie women. Plus BDSM, vampire movies, makeup, trashy dresses, getting high, getting fucked, getting fucked by boys. And I always took the criticism, the hdu’s, to heart. I knew I was a bad feminist but that wasn’t enough to make me like the things I was supposed to like. It just pushed me out of feminist spaces, and into actually pretty terrible druggy counterculture spaces, where punk guys thought it was totally legit to pull knives on their girlfriends for shooting dope.
So to make a long story not so long, I’ve got baggage.
I certainly don’t support choice feminism. I would never say that anything a woman chooses to do is feminist. But I do believe that feminists need to allow women some space, to trust us to make choices even if they’re bad choices, without constantly accusing us of stanning for the patriarchy.
In retrospect, the post really wasn’t aimed at me. I don’t follow tags, so I was missing the context, which was an insane level of bullying disguised as ship wank disguised as social justice. But the message of the post itself was, “You love the wrong things.“ And that’s a message that will always rub me the wrong way.